Arc Forumnew | comments | leaders | submitlogin
2 points by kinnard 2131 days ago | link | parent

So resoning anaphorically

testible.clef means look up the value stored at what clef evaluates to in testible

testible!clef means look up the value stored at clef in testible

testable.0 means look up the value stored (at what 0 evaluates to) in testible

testible!0 means look up the value stored at 0 in testible

atist.0 means look up the value stored at what 0 evaluates to in atist

atist!0 means look up the value stored at 0 in atist

0 of course being an atom evaluates to 0

but what if you want it to evalute to something like the key stored at 0 . . . . . . if quote means something like "don't evaluate" and unquote means something like "do evaluate" then one could reason that atist,0 means look up the value stored at what 0 evaluates to (do evaluate it) in atist

  arc> atist.0
    '(a "up")
  
  arc> atist!0
    '(a "up")
  
  arc> atist,0
    "up"
! and . behave the same with alists and numbers while its inconvenient if you want to access the key it makes sense.

Is this reasonable?

Edit: this could work for alists and insertion-ordered tables since it's unobvious how testible!0 & testible.0 should behave, numbers can and should be able to be keys so one can imagine a situation where behavior would be like so:

  arc> (= oble {1 "dream" 2 "bigger" 0 "awake"})
    {1 "dream" 2 "bigger" 0 "awake"}
  arc> oble.0
    "awake"
  arc> oble!0
    "awake"
  arc> oble,0
    "dream"


2 points by akkartik 2130 days ago | link

Pasting from my chat to you:

"Immediate reaction: this is a bad idea. Commas mean something specific in Lisp. And having `0` mean different things in different contexts is a recipe for disaster.

"I prefer aw's proposal above. Support list indexing, support alist lookup, don't support alist lookup by integer keys. Not the end of the world, people can just use `alref` in that situation."

-----